When the messenger comes, Garrett stops him, but then discreetly sends him away, without letting the girls know what he is up to.
Then, Officer Garrett Reynolds opens his car door and calls out to Spencer, but she is snarly towards him and accuses him of being a traitor and something of a stalker.
In referring to Garrett, Mike calls him "Officer Mc Friendly." Spencer meets with Garrett after her dad burns the hockey stick.
She inquires as to what the police know about the murder weapon used in Alison's death.
Later, Emily decides to trust Garrett and involves him in bribing Ian with the videos.
Garrett tells Emily that she has done the right thing, using the opportunity to fulfil Jenna's wishes in helping eliminate the videos.