Amy, in return, shared intimate details of her life to him.
The relationship was going strong, but other areas of Amy’s life were beginning to unravel.
She was doing badly in school and she lost interest in her friends and family. By August 1991, Amy was out of work and in need of money.
Allegedly, Joey suggested she become an escort at a local escort service. The Ultimatum: Within a month, Amy was making good money as a prostitute.
At a.m., with Guagenti driving, the two went to the Buttafuoco home.
By November, her thoughts about Joey and his wife had become obsessive.
She was jealous of Mary Jo, and wanted her out of the picture. Unable to cope with the break up, she cut her wrists, but the cuts were superficial.
Armed with a Titan .25 semi-automatic gun, Amy confronted Mary Jo on her front porch.
After a short conversation, Amy hit Mary Jo with the gun, causing her to fall to the ground.